North Cyprus Newspaper - Online Newspaper
Home > Opinion > Failed Government, Failed Political System


Failed Government, Failed Political System

Power cuts, a failed airline, a lack of imagination in our foreign policy, a bloated public sector- we have to wonder what is going on.

The answer is actually quite simple and is staring us in the face:  we have a government, and a political system, that is not fit to govern and, for the time being, we have no alternatives.

 

Let’s take a look at the absurdity of our parliamentary system.  In the TRNC we are, at best, a population of 250,000. And yet to support this small ‘borough’ we have 50 members of parliament each drawing a salary of perhaps US$40,000 per annum. Who knows what their indirect costs are…Compare this with the UK which has population of 62 Million and 650 MPs. Thus the TRNC with its limited resources has decided that for every 5,000 or so inhabitants we should have an MP. In contrast the UK has 1 MP per hundred thousand of population…. We could accept such a cost base in the TRNC if real progress had been made with the economy or with our negotiations with the Greek Cypriots. Instead we have to live with the fact that we have become a nation of beggars living on handouts from Turkey, and that our only seriously viable commercial activities are casinos and prostitution – and probably much of the profits from these enterprises are exported out of our country.

 

Turkey channels between US$400 Million and $900 Million per annum to us, depending on the year – thereby providing a third of the TRNC government’s budget.  I ask myself if this is the way that we repay those who came to our rescue in 1974 – by taking money from them? Is this the way we repay the families whose sons died to liberate us? Apparently this has become the way of the TRNC government. But let me say loud and clear,   not in my name, and surely not in yours either…

 

We have a Foreign Service dotted around the world – using up more of our limited and precious financial resources but for what?  Let’s take the Middle East as a case study.  Do you even know that we have ‘Representative Offices’ in Abu Dhabi, Kuwait and Bahrain?  What do our representatives do? Where are the trade links with our Sunni brothers in the Gulf? Turkey, for very good reasons, has seen its credibility grow in the Arab world. And yet we have not been able to capitalize on this. I do not want TRNC Representative Offices for the sake of my national ego. I want offices who drive trade towards us and who never tire in putting our position to the host nation.

 

Ironically,  we do have a body designed to grow inward investment – Yaga. It is to them that we leave the promotion of inward investment. And yet no organization is less equipped to deal with the outside world than this. They take money for example,  from the Islamic Development Bank and go on road shows to promote our Island with presentations, that were no doubt originally destined for a European audience, that talk about our casinos,  availability of alcohol, our tax rate, high labor costs to… fellow Muslims… in countries without taxation and where,  according to our own YAGA presentation,  they are better off sourcing labor from Jordan.

 

I would find this almost amusing if YAGA actually had a strategy on how they were really going to generate investment, private sector jobs and increase the wealth of our people. They have none -or at least none that would stand up in the real world of international business.

Let us be clear. One day there will be a settlement with the Greek Cypriots. And this is the right thing. The only questions are when, and under what terms? We need as a community to ensure the best terms and to choose the right time.   But to achieve a fair and decent settlement we have to create prosperity for our own people first. Unification will only work if we are equal partners. Right now we are not. Our GDP per capita is at 40% of the Greek Cypriots. If there is re-unification today we will become again the poor relations to be bossed around and driven in to the corner.  I say never again must we let that happen. We owe it to our parents and grandparents to fight for our rights as Turkish Cypriots. And that means that our sole focus as a nation is to create prosperity for ourselves and for our children. Prosperity gives us the resources to be better educated, to be in control of our own destinies, to be equal, to look our Greek Cypriot cousins in the eye and with confidence.

 

The old refrain of the “Greek Cypriots won’t let us” … “the embargo”… is frankly pitiful. It is the talk of victims. It is the talk of those who rely on handouts. The time has come for us to take control of our own destiny and fight the embargo. There are ways, but the government and YAGA, in their infinite wisdom are not interested, have neither the experience nor indeed the imagination to engage in the path towards economic development. We need qualified people to represent us.

Let us look domestically.  Our urban planning is a disgrace. Anyone who has driven recently on the road to Dipkarpaz will know what I am writing about. Anyone who has seen the new road being built next to Cayirova will understand the pain with which   I write…especially if they look to our mountains and see the gash in the mountain side from which they have dynamited stone for construction….We need qualified people to govern us.

I say that the time has come. The time has come only if we see that it is something important to be Turkish Cypriot. I for one happen to believe that it is something vitally important. Keeping our identity means preserving the memory of our forefathers. It means that we honor our way of life as a decent, resilient, middle of the road people – a people with a love of life and love for our land. This is something that we can be proud of. This is something that we can pass on to the next generation.

But I am not here to throw stones. Let me share with you the road map we need to follow for the sake of our future:

·         Political reform : reduce, for example,  the number of MPs from 50 to 5 – in other words one for each of the five electoral districts

·         Reduce overall government spending and progressively reduce the numbers of public sector employees as private sector jobs are created.

·         Reduce the number of wasteful and poorly managed urban development  projects

·         Reduce taxes on businesses employing Turkish Cypriot tax payers

·         Drive inward investment by creating a series of economic free zones

·         Promote and invest in high value Tourism

·         Clean up our part of the Island – so that foreigners will come and spread the word on the cleanliness and beauty of our part of the Island

·         Engage in our own right with the Ummah with a with a view to generating political recognition and attracting investment

·         Leverage the strengths of the Turkish Cypriot diaspora to tackle the problems we face

·         Work with our business community to support their growth – it is small and medium sized enterprises that are the locomotives of an economy and it is these that we need to nurture

·         Make it clear to the Greek Cypriots that we will re-unite once we have reached the same level of prosperity as them – until then ‘all the bets are off’ : up to them to help us achieve this aim if they are serious about reunification with a fair settlement for both sides.

·         Stop wasting our time on talks about solutions that if ever put in to practice would constitute a sellout of our people.

What I propose is not an overnight solution. It is a solution that will  take us a generation to achieve  but the path is the right one if we want our grandchildren to live as Turkish Cypriots, free, prosperous and as equals to their Greek Cypriot neighbors in a united Cyprus. "

 

 Metin Murat, Balalan


09.08.2010

Our Sponsor


Amy Villas
North Cyprus villa rental specialist.
www.AmyVillas.co.uk
Package Holiday North Cyprus
Unique Beach Resorts in North Cyprus & offering good value.
www.goNorthCyprus.com
Pacific Car Hire
Cheap Car Hire in NorthCyprus
www.pacific-rentals.com

 

Add a Comment



 Submitted By    
 Comment         
 CAPTCHA Image         
 Confirm Image code         
 

By:rolly on Haz 5, 2011


  

excellent artical well put. would you take on the job as head of goverment.

By:Gary on Haz 5, 2011


  

Very good article, however the only way any of the points you raised will come into play is when Turkey decide that they will give no more free diners, why should they keep bailing TRNC out when they themselves are having to reduce costs and suffer the consequences.

By:Truth Hurts on Şub 15, 2011


  

Speaking as Turkish Cypriot diaspora from Australian I'm disgusted by the article. It is nothing more than a short sighted sell-out. Especially where you refer to your "Greek Cypriot cousins"..not sure what happened in your family but no Greek is a cousin of mine. Let's get one thing straight the vast majority of the Turkish Cypriot Diaspora are anti-Greek and anti-reunification..since you long to be with your "Greek cousins" why don't you move to the South you traitor ? How quickly you forget the atrocities and murderous EOKA..the only reason we survived is because of Turkey. You put your faith in Europe just like the 8000 people in Srebrenica did.

By:Tarik Suleiman on Ara 1, 2011


  

Dear Metin, I read with great interest your article, and I share a lot of your feelings, and aspirations. How ever there is only one indicator that you need to move such an issue, is history, and the feeling of belonging. Most of the residents in Turkish Cyprus are imported, lets not hide behind our figures, will Turks in Germany become German, NO, NO , No the same with the imported Turks, they will never become Cypriots. We have more in common with our Greek Cypriots brothers than we have with them, look around you, go out look at the culture, values, you can not be blind, unless u see only what you want. Then only we can be united share common values, and leave the past behind for the sake of our children, and the future generations. We had many choices in the past; we were lead by non leaders who drove us in a dead-end. On the other hand we need our security and our economic independence, in my opinion we can achieve a lot more in working with the rest of the Cypriot, nation (we need to accept yes we won a war? at what cost? the sooner we the new generations can breach the gap then we have a future, what ever we do the Greek Cypriots will be the majority and that we are not as yet prepared to accept? are you? because the GDP gap statistically it is impossible. Unless you have a formula that economists have overlooked? We need first to be recognised and we are not and it seems we it is not going to happen either, even then survival without of the rest of eh Cypriot Nation is not possible? But not impossible either we have a choice? Remember what makes a nation is its history, its past, and how you bring all those values to your children and through the generations (and I do not mean that you do not, I think you have many valid points- but all mixed up) and I also understand your anger. And you are not the only one? It is difficult to say to some one born in Cyprus after 35 years you do not belong here any more…but ask him does he feel Cypriot, Turkish, Greek, Armenian, Maronite, Jewish, Muslim, but Cypriot? I think that is where we have the real problem?

By:Barry Davies on Tem 1, 2011


  

I have never heard such good sense spoken by a Turkish Cypriot before, I agree with everthing Murat says The part about there being too many employees is very accurate.

By:Emir Soler on Kas 20, 2010


  

This is an excellent article, just to add two things to it. Keep TRNC CLEAN campaign must start as urgency. This should start immediately through out the country schools and colleges. But most important of all, people who govern us MUST be accountable for their actions.

By:Terry O on Eki 19, 2010


  

Are the Greek Cypriots not helping their cousins in the North already? Can you not obtain a Cypriot passport? Can you not work in the South? Do you not have access to health care in the South? Does the South not supply electricity to the North? What has the North done? A simple gesture, like removing the Turkish flag from the mountain side would go along way to improving the lives of the Turkish Cypriots.

By:Dave Heaney on Kas 10, 2010


  

Lots of good points here by Metin. The TRNC should look to Full employment for all this could be achieved not by joining the Euro. Keeping your own independence. What make you think the Greek Cypriots would help you,? would they not help themselfs and their own? Build relationships with the Middle East countries these are your natural partners not the Greeks.

By:Dave Heaney on Kas 10, 2010


  

Buisness training at university level, Tax breaks for start-up buisness's free up land for the building of small manufacturing factories, produce good's which could be marketed in the Middle East this is the natural market for the TRNC. (DO NOT JOIN THE EURO.) Southern Cyprus is in a mess do not look to them for examples as they along with Greece had to be bailed out by the EU and are on the brink of bankruptcy.

By:Nurettin Omer OzOmer on Eyl 21, 2010


  

Metin-Agreed ! How and whom should take on the task of Educating old heads? Most young Professionals are leaving TRNC to study and ultimately live abroad.So the first thing to do is make it attractive for them to stay or return and help their country and people to make the changes that we all hope will happen one day.

By:Phil Read on Eyl 17, 2010


  

You have hit the nail on the head. especially the points about cleaning the North of the island up, its a disgrace, especially beaches like Alegady.

By:Ali on Eyl 13, 2010


  

Good article, however theory is one thing, practice is another. Unification will sort out a lot of the points raised. The Turkish Cypriots need that exposure, the sooner the better!

By:ERCUMENT PERTEV on Ağu 9, 2010


  

Mr Balalan, I am a turkish cypriot young person who has been drawn out of the country for several reasons that has created by the unfair system which is a dominant power over our community.I would like to congratulate you for your article addressing the real issues Turkish Cypriots are facing currently.

By:mike from larnaca on Ağu 16, 2010


  

as a greek cypriot i agree with almost all of your comments and you make alot of sense but i think the turkish cypriots are a minority in the north and as time goes along the turkish cypriots will become" extinct" by the turks.the culture and way of life will be gone.

By:Can on Ağu 13, 2010


  

I hope north cypurs is never united with the Greeks did you forget your history it's people like you that should go from this island

By:Can on Ağu 13, 2010


  

Did a Greek write this I'm not sure

By:mustafa ali on Kas 8, 2010


  

Turkey should have more say in he running of Northern Cyprus as it seems it is very managed

By:Fevzi Hussein on Kas 8, 2010


  

Metin that is a very good letter and you make lots of sensible points. I agree that it is never too late make good the wrongs of our land, but one of the real major hurdles to overcome is this - is there a genuine will to enact a positive change? At the moment the evidence suggest not. I would like

By:Sibel Hodge on Kas 8, 2010


  

Very succinctly put. I've been saying the same thing for years. We want to free ourselves of the embargoes and compete internationally, but how can we in this kind of environment? Turkish Cypriots have always been the underdogs, and as such, we have to be better, more professional, have higher goals

By:I Veli on Kas 8, 2010


  

Amazing analysis. Exactly how many of us feel. I hope there is enough people in the right position's reading this article. Our so called leaders have failed us all, its time for a massive overhaul.Well done Metin, keep it up

By:Troodo on Kas 8, 2010


  

I would add one more item to your list. Stop spitting on the people who come to live amongst us. Many with a life time of experience and who are willing to share it with us for free.

By:Suzan Nuri on Eki 8, 2010


  

I agree, an excellent article. Professionalism seems to be a word absent from the Turkish Cypriot dictionary and 'making do' will not 'do' anymore. But those of us who live abroad, who can come to the aid of our motherland, are regarded as being ignorant of the facts and interfering. What needs to

By:Jimmy McNulty on Eki 8, 2010


  

the turkish cypriots are doomed mate. i dont say that with glee. but they're too greedy, too short sighted, too selfish too succeed in the long term. they have not been educated to the point where they know what a "good government" is. they avoid efficiency like its the plague and they have been rai

By:mmunir@superonline.com on Eki 8, 2010


  

This column is the only intelligent thing I've read on the TRNC for a long time. Congratulations.

By:Geoffrey on Eki 8, 2010


  

Your article raises a large number of interesting questions, the answer to many of which is that a population this small cannot hope to generate all the talent it needs to manage things properly. .Turkey should send expertise, to protect its "investment". What I can tell you is that your

By:Erwin on Eki 8, 2010


  

Thank you Metin for such an exceptional article. Very concise and complete. I hope that all your fellow Turkish Cypriots read this and talk to their members of the government who represent them. It really is time for a change. Erwin, Bahceli and Chester

By:Ahmet on Eyl 8, 2010


  

I hope every Turkish Cypriot reads this. It should not too late for a change.

Write to us